Title: Speaking the Truth: The Smitty Bros Respond to Bitchin’ Sauce Lawsuit
In this powerful episode of the Smitty Bros SauceCast, the brothers open up about a major legal development involving their former company, Bitchin’ Sauce. What starts as a discussion about a $9.1 million lawsuit quickly becomes a broader reflection on truth, justice, family, and the values that guide the Smitty Bros’ new venture.
The Lawsuit That Shook the Brand
The podcast begins with the revelation of a high-profile legal case: a former Bitchin’ Sauce employee filed a lawsuit alleging sexual harassment, misclassification, and wrongful termination. Although the employee initially sought to settle for $1 million, the case went to trial—and the jury ruled unanimously against the company and its leadership, awarding $9.1 million in damages. Terms like malice, fraud, and oppression were used in the reporting articles about the jury’s findings.
The Smitty Bros, co-founders of Bitchin’ Sauce before they walked away from the business, make it clear that this moment—while difficult—is a public confirmation of what they’ve experienced behind the scenes for years.
“We Chose the Righteous Path”
Throughout the episode, the brothers repeatedly stress that their decision to step away from the company was guided by their values. They speak candidly about the inner conflict of watching their former brand succeed financially despite what they saw as serious ethical compromises.
Rather than staying silent, they’ve made a conscious decision to go public—sharing not only their experiences but also court-verified information in hopes of helping others see the full picture.
Not Bitterness—But Boldness
They address the likely accusation: “You’re just bitter.” But they strongly reject that narrative.
“This isn’t about revenge,” they say. “It’s about freedom. It's about speaking truth—not for our benefit, but for the benefit of our sister, her employees, and every customer who ever believed in the original mission.”
They explain that silence only perpetuates harm. By making this information widely available, they believe they’re offering others the opportunity to make informed decisions about the brands they support and the values they align with.
What Comes Next
The episode ends with a powerful promise: “We’re just getting started.”
The brothers hint at major upcoming efforts to tell the full story of their journey—from the early days of farmers markets to lawsuits and family division. Despite the heaviness of it all, they believe the ending will be redemptive.
“Justice comes first,” they say. “But after that? Mercy.”
Final Thoughts
This episode is more than a takedown. It’s a raw and honest reckoning with family, business, and integrity. Whether you're a longtime follower or new to the Smitty Bros story, one thing is clear: they’re not afraid to speak up when it matters most.
Referencing Article:
https://www.law.com/verdictsearch/subscribers/FileUpload/Report/SearchResult_02.19.25_15_22_01.PDF